Poppy's Picnic Raw Power Mince: Beef Mince review

All five recipes land in our Outstanding band, and the typical raw food lands there too. The bar in this category is set very high, and there is nothing ordinary about these labels. Each of the five finishes above the middle of the raw field, with the Beef Mince and the Turkey Mince level at the top of the group. Bone in the grind, a working organ set on every label and printed percentages against almost every entry are what earn the placing. The five sit close enough together that the honest question is which animal suits your dog, not which recipe ranks best.

Ingredients, as declared: 76% Grass Fed Beef (55% Beef Mince, 10% Beef Heart, 4% Beef Liver, 3.5% Beef Kidney, 3% Beef Ribs), Fresh Vegetables (4% Sweet Potato, 4% Green Cabbage, 4% Carrots, 4% Parsnip, Parsley), Organic Crude Wheatgerm (a natural source of Manganese), Sustainably Sourced Wild Salmon Oil (a source of Vitamin D and healthy Omega 3 fats), Natural Vitamin E from Sunflower Oil, 0.6% Kelp Seaweed (a source of Iodine), 0.44% Spirulina, 0.34% Wheatgrass, 0.2% Turmeric

Bone is the point of difference. Beef ribs at 3%, chicken drumstick at 10%, lamb ribs at 7%, turkey drumsticks at 7% and duck carcass at 8% are declared alongside the muscle meat. The calcium in these recipes is ground into the food. That is the traditional raw arrangement, and it is also why the calcium readings here run from 1.10% to 2.01% of dry matter, a good deal higher than a boneless recipe manages.

The organ set is consistent and generous. Beef heart at 9% to 10% runs through the range, with beef liver at 4% throughout and kidney between 3.5% and 4%. On the venison and duck recipe those organs are itemised at the front of the list, with no grouped percentage hiding them. Nothing a dog eats packs more nutrition into a mouthful than liver, with B12 and vitamin A in it along with copper and selenium. That is precisely why these recipes can stand without a supplement panel.

The plant side is deliberately restrained: sweet potato, green cabbage, carrots and parsnip at 4% each, with parsley after them. Naming all four means you can see what the plant fraction actually is. At that inclusion it contributes fibre and antioxidants without pushing starch into a meat-shaped recipe.

There is no vitamin and mineral premix anywhere in this range, and Poppy's says what stands in for one. Salmon oil is declared as the source of vitamin D and omega 3, and sunflower oil as natural vitamin E. Iodine comes from kelp seaweed at 0.6%, and manganese from organic crude wheatgerm. The list ends with spirulina at 0.44%, wheatgrass at 0.34% and turmeric at 0.2%. Those last three are seasoning at that level and the figures do not pretend otherwise. Wheatgrass is a leaf, and none of the gluten proteins that trouble wheat sensitive dogs travel with it.

On the analysis these read exactly like bone-in raw should. Protein converts to between 41.6% and 59.8% of dry matter, with fat between 20.1% and 38.1%. Carbohydrate reaches no more than 13.4%, and most of that is the by-difference estimate sweeping up whatever is not measured, with nothing starchy on the label. Crude ash climbs with bone content, which is why the venison and duck recipe declares 9.4% of dry matter against 3.2% on the beef.

Grass fed beef at 76%, broken out as 55% mince, 10% heart, 4% liver, 3.5% kidney and 3% ribs, which makes it the one recipe here on a single land animal. The salmon oil keeps fish on the list, so this is one species rather than one ingredient. Protein converts to 47.8% of dry matter at 153 kcal per 100g, and its calcium reading of 1.29% is the most moderate of the five.

All five are £7.11 a kilo. The pack is 450g, bought one at a time or in boxes of 8, 16, 24, 36 and 44.

On the standard maintenance estimate a 15kg adult dog in moderate condition needs about 840 kcal a day (110 × bodyweight^0.75), which on these recipes means 414g to 583g and £2.94 to £4.15 a day. The Lamb Mince is the densest of the five, and its portions are the smallest; the Venison & Duck is the lightest and feeds in the largest.