Compare dog food
Head-to-head comparisons on the factors we score. Pick a brand pairing or a food pairing to see them side by side. We don’t show prices here.
Brand comparisons
- Natural Instinct vs Paleo RidgeTop pure-raw brands (91 vs 87). Offal-rich vs fruit/veg-forward.
- Eden vs OrijenPremium high-meat dry vs dry. Roughly 38 to 40% protein vs 80/20 sporting/working (74 vs 75).
- Edgard & Cooper vs ForthgladeUK natural multi-format (78 vs 71). Replaces the dropped Lily's Kitchen pair.
- Barking Heads vs Wolf of WildernessSame-tier UK natural dry+wet (75 vs 70).
- Natures Menu vs NutrimentRaw & wet leaders (76 vs 86).
- Butchers vs NaturoAffordable UK wet head-to-head (75 vs 74).
Product comparisons
- Edgard & Cooper Adult Tins Beef vs Wolf of Wilderness Classic Tins Black RocksWet adult tins (81 vs 78). Familiar beef vs novel goat. Both brands AND products complete.
- Lifestage Raw Adult Beef vs Poppy's Picnic Mighty Mince BeefRaw beef mince (92 vs 95). Both brands AND products complete.
- Different Dog Braised Beef vs Ouzil Fresh Food BeefFresh British cooked beef (90 vs 93).
- Paleo Ridge Paleo Puppy vs ROR PuppyRaw puppy head-to-head (84 vs 95). Replaces the mismatched Pro Plan vs Royal Canin.