Product comparison
Edgard & Cooper Adult Tins Beef vs Wolf of Wilderness Classic Tins Black Rocks
A side-by-side on overall score, the four pillars, food type and declared nutrition. Figures come from our current data, and each food’s full review is linked below. We don’t show prices here.
Quick verdict
Two low-fat adult wet tins. Both sit in our Excellent band, with Wolf of Wilderness ahead. Edgard & Cooper is a familiar 60% beef recipe with prebiotic fibres and a botanical tail, labelled for adults. Wolf of Wilderness Black Rocks is a short tin built on 66% goat (meat, heart, liver and lung), a genuinely novel, organ-forward protein for adults and seniors. Close on the label, different in the bowl.
Choose Edgard & Cooper Adult Tins: Beef if…
- You want a familiar protein, because it's a beef recipe
- You like added prebiotic fibres (MOS and FOS) with a botanical tail: beetroot, pear, fennel and herbs
- You're feeding an adult and want the everyday, widely stocked option
Choose Wolf Of Wilderness Classic Tins Adult: Black Rocks if…
- You want a novel protein: 66% goat, using meat, heart, liver and lung
- You're feeding an adult or a senior, because it's labelled for both
- You prefer a short recipe of goat, stock, wild berries, minerals and a pinch of wild herbs, plus the stronger read on protein and processing
Key differences
- Score: both sit in our Excellent band, with Wolf of Wilderness ahead. It reads Excellent on protein and processing to Edgard & Cooper's Good, and both are Outstanding on nutritional balance and transparency
- Protein: Edgard & Cooper is 60% beef; Wolf of Wilderness is 66% goat, a novel, organ-forward protein
- Life stage: Edgard & Cooper is labelled for adults; Wolf of Wilderness covers adults and seniors
- Recipe length: Wolf of Wilderness keeps it short, with goat, stock, wild berries, minerals and wild herbs. Edgard & Cooper adds prebiotic fibres and a longer botanical tail
- Both are low-fat wet food: about 7% fat, high moisture, roughly 107 (Edgard & Cooper) to 112 (Wolf of Wilderness) kcal per 100g
Side by side
- Protein
- 11%
- Fat
- 7%
- Fibre
- 0.6%
- Ash
- 2.3%
- Moisture
- 78%
- Protein
- 11.6%
- Fat
- 6.8%
- Fibre
- 0.5%
- Ash
- 2%
- Moisture
- 75%
- Protein
- 50%
- Fat
- 31.8%
- Fibre
- 2.7%
- Ash
- 10.5%
- Carbs
- 5%
- Protein
- 46.4%
- Fat
- 27.2%
- Fibre
- 2%
- Ash
- 8%
- Carbs
- 16.4%
Ingredients & nutrition
Both are tinned wet food, and the recipes are built differently. Edgard & Cooper leads with 60% beef, then a little carrot and broccoli, prebiotic fibres (mannan and fructo-oligosaccharides), linseed oil and a tail of dried botanicals: beetroot, pear, fennel, caraway and herbs. Wolf of Wilderness Black Rocks is deliberately short. It lists 66% goat (meat, heart, liver and lung), stock, 4% wild berries (blueberries and raspberries), minerals and a pinch of wild herbs. The goat is a genuinely novel, organ-forward protein. The declared analysis is close. Edgard & Cooper reads 11% protein and 7% fat at about 107 kcal per 100g, and Wolf of Wilderness 11.6% protein and 6.8% fat at about 112 kcal. Both are high in moisture and low in fat, as wet food is.
Suitability & trade-offs
Both are adult tins across every breed size, and both are low-fat, high-moisture wet food, so portions are larger than a dry food's. Wolf of Wilderness stretches further up the age range, because it's labelled for seniors as well as adults. Its goat base is the pick for an owner rotating onto a novel meat or moving away from the common proteins. Edgard & Cooper keeps to familiar beef with prebiotic fibres and a botanical mix, the more conventional everyday tin. Neither is labelled for puppies, and neither needs special handling beyond normal tin storage.
Our recommendation
Wolf of Wilderness Black Rocks is ahead on our scoring, a band up on protein and processing and level on the rest, so make it the default. That goes double if a novel, organ-forward protein or senior coverage matters to you. Choose Edgard & Cooper when you specifically want beef, or the prebiotic and botanical recipe style, and the everyday familiarity that comes with it. Both sit in our Excellent band, so the gap is narrow. Put simply: Wolf of Wilderness for the stronger read and the novel goat recipe, Edgard & Cooper for a familiar beef tin.
Common questions
Which scores higher, Edgard & Cooper or Wolf of Wilderness?
Wolf of Wilderness. Both sit in our Excellent band, and it reads Excellent on protein and processing where Edgard & Cooper reads Good. Both are Outstanding on nutritional balance and transparency.
Which is suitable for puppies?
Neither, because both are adult tins. Edgard & Cooper is labelled for adults. Wolf of Wilderness Black Rocks is labelled for adults and seniors.
What protein is each?
Edgard & Cooper is 60% beef. Wolf of Wilderness is 66% goat, using meat, heart, liver and lung, so it's a novel, organ-forward protein.
Which has the shorter ingredient list?
Wolf of Wilderness: goat, stock, wild berries, minerals and a pinch of wild herbs. Edgard & Cooper adds prebiotic fibres and a longer botanical tail alongside its beef.
Are they high in fat?
No, both are low-fat wet foods, around 7% fat (Edgard & Cooper 7%, Wolf of Wilderness 6.8%) and high in moisture, at roughly 107 and 112 kcal per 100g.