Dachshund Superfood Pate Private label: Salmon & Sweet Potato review

All four trays finish in our Excellent band, level with the typical adult wet food, which is a strong field to be keeping pace with. The meat percentages do most of the lifting, because a label that prints its animal at 60% or 65% gives our reading something solid to work with. Two things put the salmon behind the chicken. A 26% share of the tray is described only as ocean fish, and its estimated carbohydrate converts to 22.2% of dry matter where the typical adult wet food runs at 15.8%. Nutritional balance and transparency read Excellent or better on every tray, protein and processing matches them on all but the lamb, and value reads Excellent across the four.

Ingredients, as declared: Salmon (40%) Ocean Fish (26%), Sweet potato (4%), Mixed Herbs (0.5%), Sunflower oil (0.1%), Prebiotic Mannan-Oligosaccharides (111mg/kg), Seaweed (55.6mg/kg), Glucosamine (38.9mg/kg), Chondroitin (22.2mg/kg), Yucca Extract (22.2mg/kg), Cranberry Extract (22.2mg/kg), Yeast Extract (11.1mg/kg), vegetables, vitamins & minerals.

Meat opens every label and does so with a figure beside it. Chicken is at 65% on the casserole, lamb at 60% on the hotpot, chicken at 60% again on the puppy bake, and the salmon tray combines salmon at 40% with ocean fish at 26%. Protein converts to between 32.0% and 48.0% of dry matter across the range, with the puppy recipe at the top of that spread, which is where a growing dog wants it.

The plant side is a small supporting cast. The casserole has sweet potato and carrot at 4% each with peas and broccoli at 1%, the hotpot sweet potato and peas, and the puppy bake brown rice at 6%. The hotpot goes a step further than most labels manage by printing both the dried weight and its fresh equivalent, so 1.3% dried carrots is declared as the equivalent of 10% carrots. That is a genuinely useful piece of honesty and it is rarer than it should be.

The extras are consistent across the range even though the labels express them in two different ways. The casserole and the salmon give mannan oligosaccharides at 111mg/kg, seaweed at 55.6mg/kg, glucosamine at 38.9mg/kg and chondroitin at 22.2mg/kg. The hotpot and the puppy bake print the same sort of amounts as percentages, glucosamine at 0.004% and chondroitin at 0.002%. Either way the levels are small and supportive. Yucca, cranberry and yeast extract sit alongside them at the same scale.

Two entries stay general. Mixed herbs appears on the casserole and the salmon without being broken down, and both of those labels close with vegetables and with vitamins and minerals, none of it itemised. No separate vitamin and trace element table is published for the puppy recipe either, its supplements being folded into the composition instead. For most buyers that is a small thing next to a meat percentage this clearly stated. It is still the one part you cannot check.

The oils differ recipe by recipe and they are worth a glance. Sunflower oil at 0.1% appears on the casserole and the salmon, a light source of vitamin E; the hotpot carries fish oil alongside an unnamed vegetable oil; and the puppy bake uses fish oil. Fish oil is a good thing for skin and coat. It is also why the hotpot and the puppy bake cannot be treated as single-animal recipes.

The fish tray, and the obvious choice if you are keeping land meats out of the bowl. Salmon is declared at 40% with a further 26% listed as ocean fish, which is a large share of the recipe left without a species against it. Its estimated carbohydrate is the highest of the adult three at 22.2% of dry matter, and sweet potato is the only vegetable given a percentage.

£7.57 a kilo across the range, in 395 g trays, with the lamb hotpot in a 380 g tray.

As a guide, feeding a 15kg adult dog in moderate condition works out at £4.86 a day on the chicken casserole, £5.08 on the lamb hotpot and £5.20 on the salmon. Those come to roughly 642, 671 and 687 grams a day respectively. The working is a maintenance need of about 840 kcal a day (110 × bodyweight^0.75, the standard estimate) and our estimated energy figures for each recipe.

The puppy bake is fed to a growth guide rather than a maintenance one, so the feeding table printed on that tray is the one to work from.