Naturediet Feel Good: Fish review

1. Lamb 77.0
2. Chicken 76.7
3. Turkey 76.7
4. Chicken 76.6
5. Salmon 74.7
6. Fish 55.8

Six recipes across Excellent and Good. Typical wet food: Excellent.

Five cartons sit close together, so among them the choice is the animal your dog prefers; the fish carton sits a clear step back.

• Fish60%Named only as fish, with no species.
• Rice12%More rice than the other five.
• Potato6%In place of the carrots.
• Dried seaweedTrace minerals and iodine; the range's only flourish.

Vitamins A and D3, selenium as sodium selenite, iron, copper, manganese and zinc, each with a figure per kilo.

The fish is not named to species, so this carton cannot help a dog avoiding one particular fish.

Energy

70 kcal per 100g

109 to 122 on the others

Fat, dry matter

8.7%

28.6% to 34.6% elsewhere

Carbohydrate, dry matter

28.3%

The highest; 9.6% at the low end

By some distance the lightest carton, for a dog that needs a lighter dinner.

Every carton declares 60% animal content and prints how it splits. Rice sits at 10% (12% on the fish), carrots or potato at 6% and dried seaweed making up the rest of a four or five line list. Protein converts to between 35.7% and 39.1% of dry matter.

Fat and starch move more: the fish carton is lowest in fat and highest in estimated carbohydrate, the salmon the reverse. The fish names no species, and the salmon carton's whitefish is unnamed too.

Price per kilo

£4.02 (RRP)

Pack

18 x 390g Cartons

A 15kg dog eats (our estimate)

575 to 700 g a day, 640 in the middle

Cost per day, 15kg dog

£2.57

Far lighter than the rest, so a big dog gets through a good deal more of it in a day.

Budget end of the market for a wet food, though a little dear for what this carton's analysis shows.