Beta Puppy: With Turkey And Lamb review

The two bags in this range finish in the same place. Both come out in our Average band, with the turkey and lamb version the narrow pick of the two. Both land under the Good that a typical growth kibble occupies. Protein and processing reads Average on both, with nutritional balance and transparency a step up in Good. The labels do nothing badly and nothing remarkably: a named dried meat at the front, a long cereal middle, soya meal carrying part of the protein, and no calcium declaration at all. That last omission is the one worth chasing. These bags are sold for every size of pup, giants included, and calcium is the figure a big breed owner most needs in front of them.

Ingredients, as declared: Turkey meal (20%), Wheat*, Corn*, Animal fats, Soya meal, Lamb meal (7%), Rice*, Wheat middlings*, Dried beet pulp, Digest, Dried chicory root*1 (1%), Minerals, Fish oil, Dried carrot* (0.07%), Dried spinach* (0.07%), Dried parsley* (0.07%), *Natural ingredients, 1natural prebiotic

Both recipes open with a dried meat meal, and that is worth decoding. The water is already out of a meal before it goes in, so the share printed on the label is close to the share that reaches the finished kibble. A fresh meat headline does not work that way. What sits immediately behind the meat on both lists is cereal: wheat, corn, rice and wheat middlings between them.

Protein reads 28.0% on both bags, 30.8% once moisture is taken out, which is a sound growth figure on paper. Some of it comes from soya meal, though, and not all of it from the meat. A pup makes less of plant protein than of the same weight of animal protein, so the number does a little less in the bowl than it does on the panel.

Fat is 14.0%, 15.4% of dry matter, and it comes from animal fats that name no species. Fish oil sits further down and is where the omega 3 for coat and brain comes from, and it is also why fish shows on the allergen picture on both recipes.

Digest is the entry most owners will not recognise. It is a processed animal protein sprayed on as a palatability coating, the reason a plain-looking kibble tastes of something to a dog, and like the animal fats it names no species.

Dried chicory root at 1% is a real inclusion, and it brings inulin, the prebiotic that the gut's useful bacteria live on. Dried beet pulp supplies the rest of the fibre, with the panel reading 2.5%. Dried spinach, carrot and parsley at 0.07% each are decoration. The label at least prints how little of them there is.

The label declares energy at 375 kcal per 100g, almost exactly the 376 a growth kibble typically carries. Portions work out much as you would expect from experience with other bags. Moisture is 9.0%, and carbohydrate converts into the low forties of dry matter, above the 39.0% typical.

The mineral panel is dosed in print: zinc at 110 mg/kg, iron at 83 mg/kg, copper at 9.2 mg/kg, manganese at 6.2 mg/kg, iodine at 2.0 mg/kg and selenium at 0.20 mg/kg. Vitamin D3 is at 1,100 IU and vitamin E at 95. What the panel never gives is calcium. This food is listed for every size of dog, toy through to giant, so that is the line most worth having. That is worth asking the maker before a big pup starts on the bag.

This version splits its meat between turkey meal at 20% and lamb meal at 7%, so a pup eats two species here. Lamb brings a richer, red meat character that some pups prefer. Soya meal climbs the list on this recipe, sitting ahead of the rice rather than behind it, which means a larger share of the protein comes from a plant source. Crude ash is 7.5%, or 8.2% of dry matter, and carbohydrate is 39.0% as fed, 42.9% of dry matter. The vitamin A dose printed here is marginally the lower of the two.

The chicken recipe is sold in 2kg and 14kg bags, and the turkey and lamb in a 14kg bag.

A growing dog's ration climbs steeply and then levels off. Use the chart on the bag as your reference point and reset it as your pup gets heavier. One scoop will not carry you through the whole of puppyhood.